Hi Verano and KrysiaD,
I will hold my hand up Verano and say that I was the person who described the Taubes book as not being repetitive, but I am used to reading technical manuals so may have a different point of view to others. –
I also felt liberated after reading it. I had been stuck in the mind set that the BSD was something you did on a temporary basis to loose the weight, but I knew that the idea of doing more than 8 weeks was controversial, and the Taubes book was the catalyst for rethinking that, however, it has also given me topics to contemplate by joining some of the dots from different chapters.
For example, in one chapter of the book there is a section where he talks about how those who are obese crave and dream about food when on restricted diets. In another chapter in one paragraph he mentions how thinking about eating a high carb dish starts the process of releasing insulin even before you have taken a mouth full, and continues to rise as soon as you start eating, so insulin is rising before the rise occurs of blood sugar. Then in another chapter of the book there is a paragraph about how people who stick to low carb diets reach a point between 12 and 18 months where they loose their sweet tooth, so they loose their cravings for carbs.
So what he is staying here is that we can’t make assumptions on insulin levels from blood sugar levels because insulin rises by just thinking about eating carbs. (In the case of someone who struggles to loose weight at 30g of carbs, and needs to drop to 20g of carbs, its possible that thinking of an alternative option to redirect our thoughts rather than sitting in an evening thinking about how nice it would be to have some chocolate or something crunchy to nibble could be significant.)
Also it raises the question, is reaching the step change of loosing your sweet tooth, or loosing your cravings for any type of carb a reflection of a reset point in the insulin system, as you have reached the point beyond the craving/release insulin in preparation for satisfying that craving cycle. After which maybe you can increase the amount of complex carbs in the diet and still loose/maintain weight.
Just because Taubes doesn’t cover how to reverse insulin resistance in this book doesn’t mean its not possible. Remember that this book was published 7 years ago, so probably any research which has been published in the last 8 years will not be covered.
We may not yet have the technology to understand the details of insulin resistance so can not measure levels of resistance or prove what techniques work, so there are no published programs to reverse insulin resistance. There is a drive within the drugs industry to come up with a magic pill solution to obesity, so there is research going on at present into insulin resistance. Doing a search on “research insulin resistance” brought up these articles which you may find interesting.
https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2016/03/160307113548.htm
https://corporate.dukehealth.org/news-listing/new-theory-how-insulin-resistance-metabolic-disease-begin
https://www.diabetes.co.uk/news/2016/oct/american-researchers-tie-insulin-resistance-to-mitochondrial-dysfunction-91747434.html
https://news.vanderbilt.edu/2018/01/25/study-may-point-to-new-ways-to-reverse-insulin-resistance/