Hi Kafin,
I am sorry to hear that you are struggling. – My personal take on the readings on the breathalyser is that the important point is to have a none zero reading. –
Each of us will have a different level of carbs you can eat without triggering insulin levels that prevent fat burning. Some of us have to be on under 20g of carbs, others can manage with slightly higher levels. – Any none zero reading on the breathalyser means that we are burning fat as our fuel source. I view that as being a very important safeguard. – The calorie counting only diets do work, but as the body is blocked from burning fat you are burning other tissues as a fuel source and that is not sustainable longterm, so the body reduces your metabolic rate to match your calorie intake. Sometimes you see advice to people on this forum that they could aim for 50g of carbs and keep on that pattern long term. But that worries me. I know from using a breathalyser myself that coming up to 21 months after starting eating low carb I drop out of ketosis if I have 30g of carb in a day. Which would mean that if I followed that advice long term I would end up risking reducing my metabolic rate further as this would be nothing more than a calorie counting diet.
So the next question on progress is how to measure progress.
Our bodies can store fat around the organs and under the skin. The fat around the organs isn’t a good place for our health, but when that fat is being burnt up, you will not see the change in body shape.
The fat under the skin isn’t limited to the waist and hips. There are a few of us that have dropped a shoe size. Most of us report seeing collar bones emerging before we see any changes in our waist and hip measurements. So a tape measure isn’t always the easiest method of monitoring progress. Sadly our bodies are designed to cope with us carrying our fat stores as a spare tyre. Especially women because our body is designed to cope with pregnancy.
I know its hard, I know what its like to want to see progress in exchange for sticking with this WoE. I still miss the early days when I had progress to report on a weekly basis and I haven’t been there for nearly a year. I have learnt that those reporting more than a small change in the scales are reporting water loss, and its nothing to envy. – I have learned to look for all sorts of signs for progress, like how tight socks feel around my calves. But somehow coming on to the forum to say that your socks don’t cut into your calves so much anymore doesn’t seem the same. 🙂 Also progress isn’t just about body shape, its about changes in tastes and emotional eating, and views of self worth.
All I can say to you is the same as I say to myself. If the breathalyser is showing I am burning fat, If my calories in are controlled and are less than those I am burning during the course of the day, then I am making up the difference from my fat stores from somewhere in my body and sooner or later those fat stores will be the ones in my spare tyre. I didn’t get to this shape in a couple of years, Its taken me all my life to build up those fat stores and that has been mixed in with yo yo dieting, so I have probably slowed down my metabolism. I have learned that it is pointless to set targets like drop in dress size or scale reading by dates, and I have learned to look in the mirror without flinching to look for changes. I have learned that my posture, and standing proud, causes people to remark on how well I look even if there hasn’t been any inch or change in the scales.
I have lost enough weight and gained enough strength to enjoy my life again, I am not a perfect shape, that’s work in progress. I still have an estimated 18 lbs of fat to burn up before I get down to an acceptable body fat percentage. However, in the process of using my body I will be increasing my muscles strength, and the strength of my bones, so I have no idea what the scales will read come the day when I get to beach body dimensions. (If I live that long), but lazing around on a beach has never been something that important to me.