In the thread ‘saturated fat’ it was suggested that I look at this YouTube clip, which I did. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qKU65ME8bmU.
It was the most impressive interview with a clearly extremely fit Finnish triathlon athlete who follows the low carb high fat regime. However, as anyone who uses YouTube will remember, when looking at a clip there are usually a number of thumbnails of more or less related clips on view down the side of the screen. Several of these were advocating the low carb diet, but some weren’t – they were slating it. I looked at some of them and was particularly concerned by a couple featuring an American doctor Michael Greger, who was slating the advocacy of high fat, in particular the ingestion of saturated fat. He was dismissive of studies that had shown low carb/high fat diets to be superior for reducing weight and BS, claiming that these studies ignored one vital factor – the role of protein. According to Gregor, the studies had been comparing high fat/low carb and low fat/high carb, but that in fact the two elements had different levels of protein so weren’t comparing like with like – that the high fat/low carb diet featured high levels of protein, whereas the low fat/high carb diets had low levels of protein. According to Greger, as an example, beef produces an immediate insulin spike higher than that produced by white potatoes – so, according to him, what I am assuming to be good is in fact bad, and vice versa.
To say the least, I am totally and utterly confused. I am not a doctor, nor a dietician, but at 79 years old I have been brought up to believe that things like apples are good for you – but they have a high sugar content – that butter is bad compared to Flora or the like – but here we are assuming the opposite. Frankly, I’m very tempted to raid the biscuit tin – except that nobody seems to be claiming that sugar is good for you – thanks for small mercies.
You only have to stand in the average high street for ten minutes to realise that obesity is a real, real problem, and it has to be caused by diet. None of the poor wretches incarcerated in the Nazi concentration camps were obese, neither were the POWs of the Japs (as were a couple of friends of mine). Obesity has to be caused by diet – and in the vast majority of cases by simply eating too much – but what is the relationship between simply eating too much and eating the wrong things?
Now, so far as I am concerned, the BSD has succeeded very well in getting my weight down, but although it has reduced my BS levels, it isn’t by much, certainly not as much as I had hoped, Other folk have clearly had spectacular success in reducing BS levels so it must work for some folk, but perhaps not all.
Mike
We have not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you are have any health related symptoms or concerns, you should contact your doctor who will be able to give you advice specific to your situation.
-
-
I saw a programme last year, may have been one of the Trust me I’m a Doctor programmes where they looked at individual gut biome results and predicted quite accurately what on an individual basis was good (by that I mean not causing blood sugar spikes) and sending people away with an individual diet plan. I think all we can do is monitor what causes spikes, water retention, bloating etc. and try to minimise them. So beef in some individuals may cause blood sugar spikes, but in many others not cause such a spike. The danger is in trying to generalise. Many saturated fats are now on the ‘good fat’ list according to the Mediterranean diet, but some still require moderation. I would try not to worry about it, keep varying your diet and discovering new favourites, and if visceral fat is still fuelling your higher sugars, one day they will drop when the visceral fat is almost all gone. Good luck with whatever you decide.
-
Refer back to my earlier post on another thread. This is not a diet high in saturated fats, no one says you should be eating FAT FAT, you should be eating good fats and other natural fats in moderation.
-
Hi Mike! I sincerely recommend you read Gary Taubes book “Why We Get Fat and What To Do About It” which has an excellent discussion of the research on low carb/high fat diets and how they work biologically. This is the research out of Duke University in the US — a highly regarded university/med school. I found this book to complement the BSD book very well and gave me a fuller understanding of why it works. It also helped calm my worried mind about fat intake.
Protein rarely causes a spike in blood sugar, so I don’t think Greger’s facts are correct, or there is more to the story.
Apples are fine in moderation! Eat some! But stay clear of fake butter like Flora — just eat good grass fed or pasture butter in moderation!
The most important thing is to avoid sugar in ALL its forms and highly refined flours and starches — a potato now and then is fine but if you are diabetic, the less starch the better.
You sound like you are a pretty healthy 79 year old! I wouldn’t worry — you are clearly doing something right!
Julia -
Thanks, folks. Sunshine girl – whihc thread was that? I’m trying to get my head round what fats are seen as good and what as bad, because I’m sure I’ve seen somewhere on here a dismissal of the idea that all sat fats are necessarily bad,
Mike -
The thread you started called Saturated Fats. If you want a list of good fats, bad fats there is plenty on the net or you could do a course with FutureLearn.com on The Science of Nutrition – just 20 mins a day for about 2 weeks if my memory is right.
Good fats, olive oil, rapeseed oil, nuts. avocados, oily fish, coconut oil for cooking. Full fat yoghurt. Full fat cheese and butter in moderation. Just watch the calories in all of these foods so you wont be able to eat too much.
Bad fats, lard, margarine, hard fat on meats, chicken skin, any trans fats and processed foods, anything labelled low fat (when fat goes out chemicals, sugars or starches are used to give flavour).To paraphrase from Michaels book – is this a low fat diet – No, fat is not the bad guy it was once made out to be. On the other hand in order to lose weight fast you will not be eating handfuls of cheese (or lashings of butter etc – my words).
Hope that helps
-
Thanks
Mike -
Whoops – that was more abrupt than I intended! Thanks again, sunshine girl – very helpful
Mike -
I’ve had a trawl through the net and I suppose that I shouldn’t be surprised at the degree of alternative theories being advanced – just looking, for example, at butter, I found it cast as a villain of the piece or a knight in shining armour and there are other such disagreements.
All I can do is go by my own experience – the BSD has done very well for me in terms of reducing my weight, but less well in reducing my FBG which was my primary reason for taking it up – it has come down, but only very slowly and only by a little, but at least that is much to be preferred to the alternative. I’m not going to abandon it – despite all the varying views across the dietary spectrum, it seems to make sense to me it its warning about high carb intakes – ‘beer belly’ is a pretty accurate description for many folk I have know over the years. Looking at some of the stuff on the net, I get the feeling that there is an awful lot of cherry picking of studies, research, etc., going on
Mike
PS just started on Gary Taube’s book – fascinating. -
Still working my way through Gary Taube’s book, but I must say that the evidence that he produced so far does seem to make a nonsense of the simplistic calories in/out concept
Mike -
Hi Mike — I felt that Gary Taubes’ first book, “Good Calories Bad Calories” was the first time I started to understand WHY I was having trouble with weight despite being a sporty/active type person and then “Why We Get Fat” gave me the HOW to change it.
I was already following Taubes recommendations when I found BSD on a journey through Heathrow and that was what finally gave me the tools to crack the code (I’m a year maintaining my healthy weight!)
I hope it helps you as much as it did me — I think I sound like a broken record but I keep recommending it. Best wishes for your journey. -
Many thanks, ma’am
Mike