Sorry for the dumb question but please would someone explain to me why it’s better to have full fat yogurt, cheese etc on this diet when the calories are lower on low fat and fat free items?
Thanks
We have not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you are have any health related symptoms or concerns, you should contact your doctor who will be able to give you advice specific to your situation.
-
-
Fat makes you feel fuller for longer, and the full fat versions tend to contain fewer carbs.
-
Genuine food containing fat is better for you than fat substitues or so-called fat free which have sugars and carbs to bulk them out ie sweet foods like yoghurt and foods like margarine or low fat spread are full of chemicals which the body struggles to process and while it is trying to deal with that it is not metabolising other foods in a way that is natural for the body. Natural fats are needed by the body to process other foods, as in my previous comments, and also to create certain vitamins. It has now been proved that full fat is better for you as your body knows exactly what it is and deals with it and it can actually help reduce cholesterol. I have had high cholesterol since my early 40’s (now mid 60’s) as well as really bad triglycerides and since this diet where I eat full fat yogs, butter and cheese, my cholesterol and triglycerides are at their lowest along with my Blood Glucose and Blood Pressure. Believe it, it works.
-
Thanks for that Sunshine girl, I’ve been mulling over why full fat is better!!
-
Thanks for those answers. Really helped me understand. G
-
I’m going to jump in with my favorite book recommendation again (newer BSD’rs may not yet have seen — sorry for those I’ve already told a hundred times) — “Why We Get Fat and What To Do About It” by Gary Taubes tracks the research around carbohydrate and fat in our diets and explains why eating full fat diets helps you lose weight. The statement (from the book) by a research Doctor that I keep in mind all the time is: “carbohydrate drives insulin drives fat (body fat)”.
Insulin is our fat storage hormone. We produce insulin in response to eating carbohydrate — and when carb intake is high and consequently our insulin levels are high, we are “storing” all the glucose in our bodies by packing it away in the cells. Insulin keeps it locked in the cells and so it is not available for your energy needs — you’ve got lots of stored energy (body fat) but you cannot access it because it is locked away in the cells. As a result you are feeling starving and weak and cold and just weird (classic low blood sugar symptoms).
When you eat full fat for your daily energy needs, by having full fat items in your diet, you lower your insulin levels and keep them low. Your body’s insulin response to fat is very small, no spikes, unlike when you have sugar. Low insulin levels allow your cells to release their stored fats and now your body is no longer in a low blood sugar state. You are not hungry and you are not weak and irritable.
To fully experience this wonderful response, the suggestions are to get your carbohydrate intake down to 20 grams or less per day. That is why you need to eat full fat — that is where more of your calories need to come from — you can only eat so much protein and there are no other options.
My experience was that over time (six months or so after I reached my goal weight) I was able to increase my carb intake but 40-50 carbs per day seems to be my personal break point, at which I WANT to eat more AND I gain weight. I think they are intimately related — if I eat too many carbs, I am storing weight and because I am storing weight, I want to eat. It is a cellular response.
My only continuing answer is full fat, low carb and moderate protein (which I increase on big workout days or ski days).
Hope that sheds some more light on why we want to eat full fat! -
Very interesting, Californiagirl, very interesting indeed. Thank you.
-
It is interesting Californiagirl, thank you. It certainly seems to make sense.
I found this article from Readers Digest which explains his thinking……………………..
http://garytaubes.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/02/WWGF-Readers-Digest-feature-Feb-2011.pdf
-
Hi Theodora and Marsie — yes, the link is really helpful and thank you on behalf of all the BSD’rs for posting the link. It gives a quick understanding of the new research that has revolutionized my thinking and ultimately, my diet.
I have struggled for 61 years, despite being a “sporty” type, to keep my weight under control. You would think that an aerobics addict, skier, hiker, yoga queen would not struggle, but I have spent forty years trying to eat in a way that didn’t make me fat.
I ate fruit for breakfast, bread for lunch and pasta for dinner — low fat, right? Not. I have never been able to control my weight until I started to restrict carbohydrate. I know it is a complete reversal from what we have been taught but I suggest that what we were taught is dangerously wrong.
My husband’s cardiologist is a good example — he recommends low fat diet and high statin dosage. The research does not really support that anymore but we are working with him to lower the statins and accept the new research.
I think we will ultimately have different advice and I know it is hard to accept the research. But for those of us who have tried and tried for YEARS and now with the new way of thinking are losing pounds (and maintaining easily) it is hard to refute.
I think the best idea is to TRY this for a few months and then evaluate for yourself. Low carbohydrate works and most of us on this forum are here because the old ideas just aren’t working. If the old ideas worked, we would be thin.
I only finally got control and lost the weight with a strict low carb diet.
Hang in there — give it a try — make up your own mind! Every body is unique and we all respond to different diets so listen to your own body. There is no one perfect solution. Listen!! -
I am on day 6 and thoroughly convinced that this diet is fantastic and definitely for me! I’ve lost 6lbs in 6 days and am starting to think that maybe I would be able to carry this on for life with a few added treats when I get my weight down (3 stone to go). I just can’t help worrying about my arteries! I get the science behind the diet I really do but there is so much research that says fat clogs your arteries up and it’s the thing I’m worrying about! I just enjoyed a beautiful lunch of mushrooms fried in butter with cream cheese and stilton on courgetti – tasted delicious – slightly marred by images of arteries becoming clogged!! Help!!
-
Thank you Californiagirl, I am really glad you posted this. I have been struggling like mad to find enough protein yet keep the carbs down. My fat is always higher than the protein and I thought that they should have been about level, but from what you are saying this is right. I do hope so because there are only so many eggs you can eat in a day and so far that’s about the only thing I’ve found since starting this diet a week ago. You have made me feel SO much better thank you
-
Thanks for the link, Theodora, interesting reading, and is from 2011! Time wasted. …….
-
Hi Janeandmosrs and Pendiente and Marsie — yes, I know what you are saying about images of clogging our arteries and having to get used to your fat intake being so high — it is just so opposite from what we have been taught and it sort of takes a “foundation shift” to accept it. I had exactly the same problem. I mean, it is ok to eat a cheese omelette but not ok to eat a big bowl of oatmeal? How could that be right? Of course, I put sugar on the oatmeal and even if I didn’t put sugar on it I usually had a blood sugar crash by 10 am but it still was hard for me to put together until I started carefully following a low carb diet. That is why I like the book I mentioned because it goes into detail and it lays out clear guidelines for a low carb diet and is a very good match-up with the BSD. The most interesting thing Taubes writes about is the history of the diet research — before World War 2, they were focused on low carb diets but there were a couple of influential researchers after WW2 who moved to low calorie/low fat for a couple of strange reasons, including the fact that President Eisenhower had a heart attack and the researchers who pushed low fat won the argument.
If you want more great diet history, Gary Taubes first book is “Good Calories Bad Calories” and it was from that book where I first started to question how I was eating and why I could not lose weight (and indeed kept gaining weight despite prodigious exercise). You might like his discussion of “Banting” which was a low carb diet craze in the late 1800’s and was one man’s personal experience with success on a low carb diet.
I go by results these days. My cholesterol is good, my triglycerides are low, my weight is stable and I can eat food and be full (and now and then I have a draft beer, my #1 favorite carbohydrate)! That’s why I recommend people just try for a few months and then evaluate for themselves. It really has changed my life. I am am grateful to BSD and Taubes for my new situation. And I get a bit peeved that no one told me before!! LOL! -
The only problem I have with Gary Taubes and all the other HFLC ‘experts’ is that they all push the idea that if you are low carb high fat then calories don’t matter. Well I am living proof that they do.
The nearest I have got to eating any form of sugar or artificial sweetener in the last 4 years is 85% chocolate. The highest amount of daily carbs I have had in that time is 40g (normally below 20g). Yet of the 4st I originally lost when I started the HFLC way of life, 3st has crept back on which is why I joined this forum. The weight gain was due to me taking my eye off the ball where calories are concerned by eating high fat items (eg nuts and dairy) at will. For example, I make a mean HFLC cheesecake which takes approx. 5min to make and an hour in the fridge, but is over 500 calories for a small portion. At Christmas I get to eat a whole chocolate log all to myself because its made with 85% chocolate, raw coco and no sugar so no one else will go near it. So it doesn’t take much for the weight to creep back up if total calories aren’t kept in check.
I suspect that’s why any form of fasting works so well for maintenance – as well as all the health benefits the body gets from having a prolonged rest from food digestion, the total calories consumed over a prolonged period of time will be naturally less.
Unfortunately this is the one piece of the puzzle they all leave out.
-
Thanks very much ddraig_goch – I’m going to order those books now!!
-
I mean California Girl thanks!! Books ordered.
-
Hi ddraig_goch — yes, that’s a valid complaint with his book — it sounds like calories don’t matter and like you, I think they do. ( Taubes does say at one point that you will have to worry about calories later) So I like the combination of high fat low carb combined with BSD. But, as I have found now that I am at goal, I can eat a lot more than I ever thought and I don’t gain weight and I am not hungry (until mealtimes and then I am ready to eat!) This is very different for me! Also, when I was actively losing weight, I lost faster and more steadily with very low carb.
And lastly, it changed HOW I eat and what food I seek out on a daily basis — I just don’t go to the sugar or refined carb anymore and I don’t try to make “alternatives” because it works better to just accept that I won’t be eating that food except only very occasionally. -
Hi Californiagirl, I quite agree with you about the faster weight loss than any other method. Having started 800F 3 weeks tomorrow I have currently lost 16.4lb. The problem for me is maintenance. I have not eaten any different foods to what I normally eat, just cut out most of the fat and upped the walking. It was the fasting bit that brought me to BSD. I did an unplanned 48hr fast last week and could have gone on quite happily and last week excluding the full fast day, averaged 636cals with no issue what so ever.
I have a feeling that over time, just as sugar becomes addictive, so can fat if eaten in large quantities over a long period of time. I suspect one of the unintended consequences of fasting is that it helps break that cycle and it reduces the minds craving for snacking if doing say a daily 16:8 fast. Before I started BSD my evening snacking was getting out of hand. Now I’m not bothered.
I intend to explore further the effect different types of fasting has on my weight loss whist on my BSD journey as I feel the momentum is there this time for me to truly get down to a low healthy weight. Last time I stalled for months and so sort of gave up. This time if I stall I shall fast if the mind and body are in sync with the idea and see if that breaks the stall quicker than might other wise have happened.
It’s also interesting how much more widely accepted high fat no sugar is becoming. When I first started on the HFLC way of life everyone thought I was nuts and it was only the repeated use of the little word NO that kept me going. Everyone thought I would either keel over or that it would be unsustainable. Now all my friends just treat how I eat as part of who I am and no one takes unbridged at me either not eating or bringing my own food. Those that do I just mention the word allergy to and they are either fine with it or not worth bothering with in my book.
-
Fat doesn’t make you fat, sugar (ie carbs) make you fat. I read Dr Bernsteins book , the diabetes solution, and there was a really interesting thing he said about farmers who, when they want to fatten up their livestock, they don’t feed them butter, cream etc, they feed them grain. Now I know we are humans, and our bodies are different, but in many way the principles are the same. If you read The Real Meal Revolution, there is a really interesting chapter on how the whole low fat thing came into being, and it basically stems from President Nixon in the USA, on his campaign trail wanted to get the farmers on side, so made promises regarding crops, the cheapest thing to produce was maize and corn, but they then had to find a use for it all. Welcome high fructose corn syrup etc. They also used doctored studies to convince people that high fat diets were to blame for rising heart problems, and it basically all stems from there. There is a LOT of information out there regarding healthy fats and how they help not harm when used in a lower carb diet. We have been conditioned to believe that low fat is healthy, and that fat clogs arteries etc, but the reality is starting to emerge slowly that those facts are not actually based on real studies. For years we have been told “low calorie, low fat” is the way to be healthy, but if this were true, why is the obesity epidemic continually rising. The Diet Doctor also has some really interesting reading on his website, especially regarding diabetes https://www.dietdoctor.com/diabetes
-
Can anyone tell me what happens to excess fat in the diet if you eat a very low carb high fat diet but end up eating more fat than is utilised. Does it get metabolized in some way and end up as fat storage or does it all get excreted? Suddenly realized I don’t know/can’t remember and doing a quick trawl of the internet hasn’t helped.
-
ddraig-goch, I think California girl has give a fullish answer above, scroll back up to find.
-
Hi Pendiente
After all the brain washing that we’ve had to endure over the years I’m not surprised that you have concerns about the extra fat in our diets clogging our arteries.Since starting this way of eating 12 months ago, my triglycerides have gone way down and my HDL has gone way up and you should see the amount of fat I eat!
I’m now on maintenance so am not restricted to 800 calories anymore and for breakfast this morning I had 2 pieces of bacon, 2 double yolk eggs, a piece of haloumi and an avocado. All fried in butter! Yum!
That will keep me going until dinner as I just won’t feel like eating at lunchtime.
Here’s a link to some websites that may explain the theory and put your mind at rest.
https://www.dietdoctor.com/1-low-carb-fear-saturated-fat
&
https://www.ketovangelist.com/keto-and-cholesterol/
Any questions, just ask
Cheers
Linda -
Thanks LindaA,
They’re really interesting, useful links (if a bit mind boggling about cholesterol). I get it but I’m so confused. A month ago my 55 year old brother in law had chest pains which resulted in a stent being fitted in his heart. It was blamed on diet (number 1 – and they specifically blamed high fat) and salt and lack of exercise as well as being inherited, as his cousin had quadruple bypass in his 40’s and my father in law died of heart failure – although he was 76 so not that unusual. Because of this my family have been advised to get checked for cholesterol, even my kids who are teenagers. It’s like who do we believe?! If Dr’s are beginning to catch on then why don’t they spread the word a bit more quickly?! I guess I’m terrified of advising my kids to do the wrong thing – and myself! Mind you a couple of things in those videos stood out – one Dr saying natural saturated fat is ok but fat made in a factory is not, and the female Dr saying saturated fat is okay so long as we don’t do anything to it.Anyway I am convinced I just need to do more research I guess. My first full week and half a stone YES half a stone down and I’ve just measured my waist and have lost one and a half inches. I am amazed and so so pleased! Had bacon, eggs, tomato and mushrooms for my breakfast and going for an hours march up the beach soon! ]
LindaA, you say you’re on maintenance now – are you finding that okay? Are you just cutting carbs but otherwise staying with the same principles. If you don’t mind me asking how much weight did you lose and how long did it take?
Again, many thanks xx
-
Hi Pendiente
It’s very confusing isn’t it with different info coming from everywhere.The information regarding ‘seed’ or processed vegetable oils is correct.
I no longer eat canola, rapeseed, sunflower, safflower and other similar oils due to their high polyunsaturated oil levels and highly processed nature.
I eat loads of butter, lard, duck fat, coconut oil and some olive oil.
If you can, read ‘Toxic Oil’ by David Gillespie, it explains a lot.I started in April last year and lost 30kg in around 25 weeks and have been maintaining since September. I changed nothing about my eating from the BSD other than to eat more fat. My carbs and protein levels remain the same and I don’t count calories. My HDL has gone up and my tryglicerides have gone down. There’s a great book ‘Cholesterol Clarity’ by Jimmy Moore that explains the whole cholesterol thing really well. Well worth the read.
Also, if you can, read ‘Good Calories, Bad Calories’ by Gary Taubes. It’s great at explaining all the science.
I’ve done a lot of reading over the last 12 months which has helped me understand what the science has revealed but that mainstream doctors are not following.Ultimately, you have to do what you feel comfortable with, but knowledge is power.
Cheers
Linda -
Thanks LindaA – that’s really helpful. I’ve ordered one book by Gary Taubes so I’ll start with that one and continue educating myself! Having spent most of my life on a diet and never getting very far I now feel like there’s been a conspiracy!!
Well done – wow 30kg that’s amazing you must be so pleased – and to continue maintaining is great too. Inspirational as are lots of these forum posts!