A medium carb low calorie diet – any issue?

We have not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you are have any health related symptoms or concerns, you should contact your doctor who will be able to give you advice specific to your situation.

  • posted by Emmie
    on
    permalink

    I’m morbidly obese and due an operation soon to fix a pelvic prolapse. The consultant has advised me that he wouldn’t operate unless I was under 35 BMI. (Currently 41)

    I read the BSD book earlier this year and really felt like it would be good to try as soon as I got the motivation to do so and latest news from doctor was good motivation!

    I didn’t have time to prepare diets as my husband was going away so for a couple of days I just did a low calorie diet but not a no carb one. My carbs are relatively high – but it’s working and I’m not hungry. I’m relatively active as well.

    My current thinking is if it’s not broken don’t fix it!! I have one or two bowls of cereal with full fat milk and a low calorie dinner like soup with one small slice of bread or a chicken breast and salad. Only have water or coffee and full fat milk in the day time. About 1000 calories a day. Is this an ok diet for rapid weight loss?

    Any advice welcome! Thank you.

  • posted by Frog
    on
    permalink

    You may find that if you drop the simple carbs, you will lose weight faster – the bread and cereal, for example.
    You’ll probably find that the cereal has a lot of sugar in it as well.
    you may find it useful to use this site, but pretty much everyone here is restricting carb intake – that’s kind of the main focus of BSD – why not try it?

  • posted by sandylane
    on
    permalink

    This diet is about measuring and keeping to carb and calorie limits. I use Myfitnesspwl to measure everything going in my mouth. I know from practice that cereal and bread are an absolute no, as they would blow your carb limit and leave you with insufficient calories to accommodate the protein and fat you will need. Ditch the carbs.

  • posted by Jenni from the Block
    on
    permalink

    As Sandylane has said, the BSD diet is about low carb. If you want your BMI to come down, particularly fairly quickly to facilitate your operation then what you have described is high carb and unlikely to bring about the change you seek.

  • posted by Emmie
    on
    permalink

    Thanks so much for all your support, I understand what you’re saying and I’ll read up better about low carbing.

    When I have tried eating low carb before I always felt hungry. I wonder if my body is just craving carbs rather than being hungry?

    I also find it really difficult to eat a plate of veg which is part of my reluctance.

    But youre right, if I want a more dramatic weight drop I should probably reduce carbs. Thank you for your help.

  • posted by sunshine-girl
    on
    permalink

    Hi Emmie, it is possible that your body is craving carbs but also, are you eating enough healthy fats and protiens. If you really want dramatic weight loss you should ditch the simple carbs completely, no potatoes, bread, rice, pasta, breakfast cereals (so full of sugar) and sugar, and obviously no pies or cakes or processed meals. That is how this works. If you are diabetic this principle is the most important for reducing Blood Glucose, if you are not diabetic (you don’t say but I assume not) then the odd sneaky bad carb will not hurt but will slow down your weight loss. You say you can’t face a plateful of vegetables. Have you got the recipe book or seen the recipes in the back of MM’s original book, or even on the Recipes page on this site. There is no need to live on veg. I tend to have veg type meals at lunchtime but not the usual boring salad stuff I used to eat, I now look forward to trying lots of things. My favorite lunch is roasted chicken breast, cooked with roasted red pepper and roasted asapargus, served on a bed of fine sliced courgette, add to that a dressing of yoghurt with garlic, lemon juice and olive oil. Okay, so veg but it tastes so different when roasted. Looking at my menu for this week, for my dinners I have had, pork in mustard sauce, skinny cottage pie, frittata (to empty my fridge before shopping day), coq au vin, turkey burgers, luxury fish pie and tomorrow a roast pork joint minus the spuds.

    What on earth is boring about that. Get the books, get reading and get creative and you will enjoy your food more than before. Don’t forget to have healthy fats, oil dressings, avocado, nuts for snacks and so on. Also keep up your protiens like fish, chicken, eggs, cheese. The only thing you are ditching are the stodgy boring bits of a meal. Rice and pasta are just gloop in the mouth without a sauce, you wouldn’t want to eat them if that was your meal, a plate of rice. Okay, roast spuds…… but lets not think about that yet.

  • posted by Frog
    on
    permalink

    well put Sunshine Girl – yep, a plate of roasted vegetables sounds far more appetising than a plateful of rice – or of pasta.

    Reminds me that I saw a small spiralizer for £3 in Tesco yesterday – it was the pencil sharpener type one, and literally just the cone part with a blade.
    Having invested in a large one (all of £12!) I wouldn’t go back to a small one, but a useful way to try out spiralised veg.

  • posted by Jande9
    on
    permalink

    Hi Emmie, I am not an expert but it doesn’t sound like you would be getting enough vitamins on your diet. I was a little bit like you. I loved homemade bread and other grains but I ate my veggies pretty unenthusiastically. My mother was a terrible cook and all our veggies were out of cans. Even potatoes.
    I found my gateway food to healthy eating was lentil soup. There is nothing like homemade lentil soup to wake up your taste buds. There are recipes everywhere but my favourite adds a bit of cumin and curry powder. A bowl at lunch lasts me all afternoon.
    Good luck.

  • posted by SunnyB
    on
    permalink

    Just want to offer some encouragement Emmie. You really would be better to using a low carb diet for seeing good results. If you make sure you have enough fat and protein included in your meals, you will find that you won’t feel hungry – at least not once your body has adjusted to the new regime.

    It is common for people to experience cravings for carbs, hunger pangs and headaches in the first few days, but this usually rights itself by the end of a week. It’s your body crying out for carbs, but once it’s adjusted you will find it easier to stick with the low carbs and you should see encouraging progress quite rapidly. Try moving to decaf if you don’t want to drop you coffee Make sure you keep your fluid intake up, as good hydration is important.

    Anyway, hope you achieve the loss you are looking for so that your op can go ahead. Keep us posted on progress and good luck with it.

Please log in or register to post a reply.