Should I overshoot my target weight?

We have not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you are have any health related symptoms or concerns, you should contact your doctor who will be able to give you advice specific to your situation.

  • posted by Jande9
    on
    permalink

    When I started the diet I lost a lot of weight the first few days, I’m guessing all water. When I finish the diet and start to eat more carbs I assume I will regain some of this lost water weight.

    Should I overshoot my weight goal to account for the rebound effect, and if so, by how much?

    I went from 196 pounds to 191 pounds in three days. Should I therefore assume I will rebound about 5 pounds and set my end of diet goal to be 5 pounds less than my final desired weight?

    Thanks for any ideas on this.

  • posted by shalimar
    on
    permalink

    I am not sure water weight you lost weeks ago has anything to do with anything.

    Your target weight …..

    see how you feel
    are you happy with the weight and your body shape
    are you happy with your measurements
    are you happy with your BMI
    are you happy with your blood sugars

    Are you planning on going back to your old ways of eating?

    What kind of maintenance are you going to do?

    Just my thoughts … those are the questions i am going to ask myself when i reach/near my goal?

  • posted by captainlynne
    on
    permalink

    I agree with everything shalimar says.

    I had a target weight in mind. When I reached that I decided to lose more to give me some wriggle room. Then I decided to lose another two pounds (to reach the round figure of 100 pounds) but overshot by another pound.

    This is the way of eating I will follow for life. I’m slowly increasing calories but staying low carb. My blood sugars are down in the normal range, I’m comfortably in the health BMI.

  • posted by Frog
    on
    permalink

    Hi Jande
    Many of us that still post after several months of BSD, have phases of strict BSD and ‘relaxed BSD’ – and may recycle a pound or two for a while, then drop again if we start being strict again – we haven’t reached target, so not strictly maintenance, but….
    If you maintain while sticking to BSD principles, you’ll probably stay at around the same weight, just keep a check on it and now you know how to loose it again if there is some ‘creep’. If on reaching your target you resume your old eating habits, then the pounds are likely to pile back on.
    When you do reach your target, decide how you’re going to maintain, and monitor to make sure that you do stay where you want to be.

  • posted by Hedgey
    on
    permalink

    I think that it’s said that the amount you lost in the first week is the amount you would normally put back on when carbs + water are stored again when you go back to eating normally and you regain your emergency stores of glycogen. So your actual sustainable weight loss would be total amount lost minus the first week’s loss.

    You can Google it for other viewpoints and theories but this site explains it http://www.phlaunt.com/diabetes/43067073.php

    Whether it’s right or not I don’t know but it’s a common theory at least.

  • posted by Jande9
    on
    permalink

    Thanks Hedgey. That is an interesting article. It is good to be reminded that the object of the exercise is to lose fat. I will definitely overshoot my ultimate goal.

    Jan

  • posted by Trish45D
    on
    permalink

    I cannot speak for anyone but myself, I intend to go 6 kg below the top of my healthy BMI. One to avoid any anxiety about gaining that fluid/glycogen back (which can be as much as 1-2 kg) and also because you should try to have a weight range in maintenance and that range can be anywhere from 1-3 kg.

    Honestly, you won’t really know until you get there so don’t be too quick to call goal, live at it for a while and see how it feels, how well you can handle the fluctuations in maintenance. If it freaks you out to see the scale weight move up 2 kg in a week then ask yourself if this weight is the correct one for you. However, remember you should try to gain muscle as soon as you go into maintenance and muscle may add weight to your body but even if it does your clothes should start to fit better. Not all weight gains are bad. Mind you, muscle gain can take months or years.

  • posted by Monad
    on
    permalink

    I think this is a good idea and am planning to do the same. I have now achieved my initial target weight and have regained a healthy BMi but it’s still at the upper edge and I can feel there are still a few pounds around my midline so want to push myself further. The next 4 weeks I am planning to follow the Gut makeover diet by Jeanette Hyde because I have recently come off antibiotics and my gut biota needs rebalancing, plus this will eliminate the last sources of sugars and saturated fats from my diet (and no meat or coffee at all for the first 2 weeks).

  • posted by Jenni from the Block
    on
    permalink

    I find it disconcerting when another diet is named on this site. If commenting on gut bacteria diets that may be relevant but better not to name another diet product. We are trying to stick to a particular eating plan and diversions don’t assist on our journeys.

  • posted by Monad
    on
    permalink

    Sorry I didn’t think of it as a ‘product’ really, just another source of advice and it doesn’t seem at all incompatible with Michael’s stuff so shouldn’t be a diversion – just that it adds some consideration of our little helpers, without whom we would be unable to process most foods but that also mediate how well we process fats and carbs (and thus impact on weight loss/gain).

  • posted by Monad
    on
    permalink

    Since I last posted I am now 2KG under which is a start – I’m aiming for 2 more then I will be happy

Please log in or register to post a reply.